John Craven Mark Cray

Seth Hayden Devin Kates

Holly Craven Kati Jordan

Alex / Masked Victim Jonathan Adam Duerr

Vince Kyle Znamenak

Christian Mike Hinkle

Kyle Tom Allen

Chester Donnell Kevin Ashley

Nicki Rebecca Lynne

Victim Erica Soto

Victim Ashley Henke

Victim Sarah Domanick

Danielle Danielle Cray

Victim Jessica Hsu

Victim Bill McCue

Robert Hayden Tony Kates

Victim Amanda Hughes

Victim James Flahart

Newscaster (voice) Fearon Derry

Kaylah Anne Reiss

Samantha Hayden Beth Kates

Grey Mortimer David M. Sitbon

Girl Tiffeny Cray

Robin Hayden Dakota Skye Kates

Jeffrey Jay Cusack

Eligio Bonelli Anthony Mecca

Girl Ambrosia Cray

Victim Joseph Drobezko

Tara Hayden Nina Kates

Pastor Vernon Cole Steve Brown

Karen Melissa Torrence

Dylan Hayden Dominic Kates

Girl Amber Cray

Detective Chris Dolendo Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.

Victim Colin Irving

Victim Julian Bates

Victim Joshua Howton

Victim Jenny-Lynn Azwol

Victim Angie Rizzo

Victim Alexandra McCue

Victim Vikki McCue

Victim Monica McCue

Victim Janet Jay

Victim Grace Flynn

Victim Jessica Lee

Victim Kara Boland

Wayne Montgomery Paul McCloskey

Andrea Montgomery Barbara Lessin

Detective John Haynes Michael J. Panichelli Jr.

Monica Montgomery Emily Spiegel

Jared Joey Garrison

Cameron Robert Z'Dar

Julie Brinke Stevens