Desire / Witch Natalie Peri

Char Julie Anne Prescott

Ari Carson Will Collazo Jr.

Bridgette Heckel Heather Harlow

Good Mel / Bad Mel / Anne Melissa Heflin

Grace Erica Dyer

Nancy/Victim 1 (archive footage) (Uncredited) Tina Krause

Carl Steel Clint Beaver

Joffrey Kyle Rappaport

Victim 2 (Uncredited) Jennie Russo

Mr. Carson George Stover

Lisa Avery Jamie Morgan

Stuart Lincoln David Perry

Seth Warren Dean Fulton

Emily (voice) Rouge Rose

Marvin Marvin Maddicks Jr.

Theo Konvitz Steven Haar

Rudy Ledbetter Rudy Ledbetter

Entity (voice) Christopher Korek

Will Oaks Tim Hatch

Ronnie Ronnie Nanos

Ed (voice) Edward Haynes Jr.

Sophia Flemmich Noellie Burger

Scruffy Duffy Thomas Antalek

Les Les Nolan

Rusty Parr Kellen DeRuy

Brad Stamper Thomas J. O'Brien

Kenneth Keith Kallenbach Steven Kiseleski

Tony Andrews Eric Norcross

Sara Taylor Jen Elyse Feldy

Brett Brett Clark

Father (voice) Matt Skinner

Ashtray Jones Josh Kelley

Hatch (voice) HB Gibson

Randall Cheeks Paul "Duck" Tucker

Jeff Senese Forrest Bennett

Mark Flemmich Mark Flemmich

Griffin Graves / DJ Johnny Slacks Bill Dawson

Tricia Lee Rachel Max

Brannan Brannan Durham

Hy Pyke Jeffery Woods

Ranger Mason Andy J. Davis

Charlie Charlie Skinner-Cheverie

Dark Priest Mark C. Fullhardt

Nathan Nix (voice) Shawn Ness

Theo Dan Romano

Valerie (voice) Valerie Strong

Ivan James Janso

Todd Henrickson Bobby F. Murphy

Cult Member Francis Erdman

Rory Stephen Bloodworth

John John Henderson

Cody Cody Tudor

Stanos Marc Chindemi

Mike Mike Redman

Survivalist Shannon Hall

Cult Leader John Ward

Damien Thorn Niko El Santo Zavero