Charlotte Sydney Hirsch

The Bottom Butcher Zac Amico

Artie Fambuglio Ian Fidance

Brack/Joey Carbone Johnny Ferri

Jennifer Roth Amanda Flowers

Therapist/Father Tomas/Lt. Finch Marcus Bishop-Wright

Det. Cabot Jaime Lutz

Greggie Billy Bob Thompson

Tara Jen Elyse Feldy

PJ Kelly Polk

Harmony Rachel Francis

Johnnie Lee Conor McCarthy

Claudette Bimini Lee-Wright

Sam Pat Foy

Ruby Jean Louise O'Sullivan

Houseman Abraham Sparrow

Dr. Sara Carmichael Steph Shober

Lil Tony Damante Dominick Denaro

The Mad Monk/Narrator Lloyd Kaufman

Sister May Teresa Hui

Caroline Menders Dylan Mars Greenberg

Sister Anne Lisa Gaye

Angie Heather Sprow

Gio Lou Perez

Walter Dahnger Alan Ceppos

Father O'Donelly Vito Trigo

Walter Dahnger III Seby X. Martinez

Goon #1 Doug Sakmann

Young Jennifer Polly Jean Bassham

God / Goon #2 / Butt Boy / Detective / Inferno Clubber Diego Santos

Flower Girl / Inferno Clubber Erin Triplett