The Pie Guy Joshua M. Lester

Sophia Skye LaFontaine

Garret Greg Hirshland

Tommy Sam Anker

Jackie Collins Amanda Westlake

The Therapist Colette Freedman

Kim Charlie R. Parker

Baylee Julia Fae

Supervisor Keegan Ferguson

Dad Ed Regine

Mom Varda Appleton

Ex-Girlfriend Shikira Saul

Nolan Neil Lars

Goth Girl Deidre Lee

July Amanda Rivers

Barry (TV Show) Dante Bisson

Pie Bartender Louie Caceres

Ryan August Edwards

Leonard (TV Show) Jorge Espinoza

Pie Bar Owner Laurie Gray

Emily Carolina Montenegro

The Blonde Arielle Raycene

Half Naked Guy Thomas Sapin

Bartender Logan Solberg

Brooklyn Pizza Worker Eddie Streeter

Dr. Stephenson Elle Sunkara

Co-Worker Colleen Tholen

Co-Worker Kaleb Tholen

Middle Bar Date Ndi Wilson