Ben Justin Rose

Allyson Kelly Curran

Professor Nolan Gallagher Rocco Guirlanda

Jennifer Seraphina Anne Zorn

Grace Shelby Brunn

Puppy Love Boy Deacon Hayward

Shakespearean Professor Louis Badalament

Teen Boyfriend Jeremy Kaluza

Horse-Head Man Charlie Hunt

Ben Senior Jon W. Martin

Tracy Christy Edwards

Girl in Movie Amy Drohan

Romantic Girl Katelyn Kabel

Rude Customer Howard Farmer

Student at Comedy Club #3 Sarah Dean

Engineering Student Anna Bauman

Student with Sandwich Joel Bradley

Female Street Musician Megan Fluharty

Mom #1 Lissa Strodtbeck

Woman at Bar Treasheer D. Allison

Max from High School Zach Barber

Teen Girlfriend Jordan Borges

Student at Comedy Club #2 Satin Quiroz

Blind Customer Robert Busha

Comedy Club MC Jacari Britton

Student at Comedy Club #1 Katherine Tasma

Rebound Date Logan Hurtado

Mom #2 Stacy Hayward

Cinema Employee Joseph Cassidy

Dad #1 John Strodtbeck

Hat Store Clerk Elisha Gidron

Mother in Audience Kasey Palmer

Student at Comedy Club #4 Brianna Buller

Street Guitarist Tyler Thorne

Male Street Musician Derek Hiler

Lonely Guy Ryan Warriner

Dad #2 Nicholas Hayward

Puppy Love Girl Gillian Strodtbeck

Horse-Head Man's Buddy Jason Brophy

Waiter Dan Faultersack

Stand-Up Comedian Steven Owsley

Fry Cook / Bartender Justin Lundy

Girl in Audience Riley Ellis

Romantic Guy James Stump

Stage Actor DeJuan Bland