Billie Rachel Alig

Harley Amber Herfurth

Sam Sean Walsh

Carl Nick Chandler

Diglett Patrick Garrigan

Steve 'The Watchman' Alex Dittmer

Brenda 'The Dreadful Ghoul' Heather Call

Grace Grace Reinhardt

Richard Tyler Amm

The Assassin Chris Aubry

Baby Brute Andrew Baker

Papa Brute Chris Baker

Cult Emily Baker

Cult Stand In Katie Baker

The Monitor Alex Bergman

Cult Stand In Matthew Birtell

Cult Ethan Boin

Christmas Girl Caylee Bourdoin

Avery Avery Buckingham

Cult Sacrifice, Cult Stand In Joe Buckley

Cult Jennie Carpenter

Cult Amber Cassell

Cult Preacher Dan Churney

Cult Zander Dziedzic

Cult Hunter Faux

Game Booth Carny Allie Fishman

Cult Micheal Flaherty

Bar Patron Sloan Gretencord

Doug's Bloody Friend Daniel James Halm

Cult Bryan Michael Hartnett

The Hag Natalia Ann Hrovat

Cult Dakota Hungerford

Cult Sylvia Hyatt

Cult Stand In Joe Jakupcak

Lanky Brute, Demon Pawel Kaniewski

Kennedy Ashley Keegan

Waitress Mackenzie Killelea

Waitress Quinn Kistenferger

Bar Patron Andrea Lippert

Cult Matthew Maggio

Bar Patron Mario Manrriquez

Doug Trevor McCandless

Cult Stand In Sam Michaels

Cult Jacob Montgomery

Cult Kelly Montgomery

Cult Evan Morency

Officer Henderson Paul D. Morgan

Bar Patron Randy Noy

Pee Pants 'The Spared' Edgar Patino

Craig Craig Peck

Waitress Patricia Pruitt

Marcos Marcos Rabadan

Grace's Mother Miranda Reinhardt

Cult (as Nicholas Scott) Ryan Satterfeal

Cult Tech Guy Kristopher Smith

Cult Stand In Emily Swain

Undead 'Puppet' Half-Goat Nick Swartz

Christmas Girl Karly Swords

Cult Blake Tyson

Cotton Candy Man Jim Uremovic

Marc Giuseppe Urso

Bartender Benjamin Van Vactor

The Bra Carney Sara Bonnie Walsh

Game Booth Carny Emily Weber

Kyle Kyle Wilkinson

Phil Gunderson Marc Wilkinson

Cult Stand In Rebecca Wilkinson

Game Booth Carny Ryan Matthew Ziegler