Judas James Murray

Jesus Jeremy Guskin

Manuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez Ronney Ascher

Mrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman Marti Cooney

Mr. Baker Laurence Frommer

Mary / Disgusted Angel Elizabeth Wood

Joseph David Skigen

Lawn Mower Boy / Extra Sal Vulcano

Larry Matthew Glass

James Peterson / God / Smitty Hank Poje

Vinny (as Jonah Zieger) Jonah Zeiger

Play Angel Kelley Rae O'Donnell

Herbie Falafen David Hubbell

George James P. Murray

Dr. Puglia / Yelling Angel Lino Alvarez

Moses Pete Barker

Noah Ken Dray

Ham Slicing Boy Dennis Meehan

Sandy Weinberg (as Hillary Gouse) Hillary Ayn Ryan

Max Weinberg Lyle Silversmith

Ezekiel Weinberg Jason Hom

Scared Angel Jonathan Beatrice

Roman Centurion / Extra Colin Liander

Roman Centurion Michael Rigby

Satan Patrick Nicholas

Bar Wiping Boy Christopher Morgan

Bar Tender Assistant Bennato Pennella

Extra Andrew Hanniffy

Extra Brian J. Jamieson

Extra Glenn Klein

Extra Cara S. Liander

Extra Robert Liander

Extra (as Kenneth Miller) Kenneth Robert Marlo

Extra Matty O'Shea

Extra Michael Onorato

Extra Heather Taylor-Simpson

Extra Jim Walsh

Extra Pam Bernstein